bradgreer
Full Fledged Farker
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2014
- Location
- Smithfie...
I have been reading a frustrating post on Facebook about KCBS CBJ and sampling multiple preparations in the same box IE brisket slices and burnt ends for example.
What was a bit disconcerting was how many judges said that if they were presented two items one being excellent and one being not nearly as good, that they would score the entire entry based upon the lower score!! :shocked::mad2::tsk:
So if you submit brisket slices that are excellent (9) and burnt ends that are a (7) they would score the entry as a 7, when it clearly states in the handbook not to do it this way.
If the KCBS doesn't think that the judging system needs some "tweaking" they are up in the night.
At the very least, the judges should be on the same page.
What was a bit disconcerting was how many judges said that if they were presented two items one being excellent and one being not nearly as good, that they would score the entire entry based upon the lower score!! :shocked::mad2::tsk:
So if you submit brisket slices that are excellent (9) and burnt ends that are a (7) they would score the entry as a 7, when it clearly states in the handbook not to do it this way.
If the KCBS doesn't think that the judging system needs some "tweaking" they are up in the night.
At the very least, the judges should be on the same page.