I assume that the score of 1 is applied to a multiplier thus there is score as shown on the sheet.
All 1's would yield a weighted score of 20, not 114.
I assume that the score of 1 is applied to a multiplier thus there is score as shown on the sheet.
All 1's would yield a weighted score of 20, not 114.
I was a judge at that table. We were told only to score a 1 for appearance and enter scores for taste, tenderness, by the rep.Their scores for pork are as follows...
Judge 1: 21.2000
Judge 2: 21.2000
Judge 3: 21.2000
Judge 4: 23.4972
Judge 5: 22.3428
Judge 6: 25.7828
Total: 114.0228
How is that a DQ when all judges are to score a 1 in all criteria?
It's only 1's for appearance. Taste and tenderness are scored as usual.
It's only 1's for appearance. Taste and tenderness are scored as usual.
I was a judge at that table. We were told only to score a 1 for appearance and enter scores for taste, tenderness, by the rep.
9) Meat shall not be sculptured, branded or presented in acriteria by all six judges.
way to make it identifiable. Rosettes of meat slices are not
allowed. Violations of this rule will be scored a one (1) on all
So speedracer you were at table 1. Judge 3 was a tough judge at that table. Seem to be the lowest scoring judge of the contest. didnt seem like he/she liked any entry.
What am I missing? The rule states 1's for all criteria.
From the rules (bolding by me):
[/LEFT]
And as if all this wasn't enough we got pulled over at the entrance to the Queen's Midtown Tunnel and asked to open our van. The let us go pretty quickly but the cops did tell me I was the second team they had stopped coming from Medford, I'm thinking BBQ Mafia but I could be wrong.
That pork came to my table. (I was not the one who called it out.)
I thought the appearance was a 5 or 6 and scored it before another judge called the table captain on it. Who called the rep over.
Mike Lake looked at it for about 10 seconds and declared it molded.
Technically, maybe yes, but I would have let it be judged on it's own.
Im curious for those in this thread that are saying that it was a bad call and questioning mike lake. Have any of you ever turned in an entry like that?