Discussion Thread -> ""WSM/Bullet Smoker vs. Kamado!"!" Throwdown (Entries and Quality ON TOPIC *CLEAN* Discussion Only)

Official Entry and Such

Please use this pic for Entry:

vpx2jn.jpg


For a non flowerpot Real backyard Smoker please see the link below :grin::

http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/showthread.php?t=191976
 
Hi! This is my official WSM VS Flower Pot TD entry. :becky:

I was planning on entering on team flower pot but I'll be damned if Home Depot or anybody else in my area didn't have any pansies in stock. :mmph:
WTF apparently they don't come out until fall (yeah the equinox not the solstice). :tsk:

So I guess I'll just have to enter on team bullet.

This news didn't go over very well with a certain somebody...



Yeah as you can tell he's pissed. Well I kind of convinced him that he would be in charge of the important stuff, I mean really you cant have a cook without first lighting some briquettes. He didn't really buy it so I just flipped his top anyway. I mean really who's the boss here anyway?



I decided to do some ribs rubbed with Oakridge BBQ secret rib rub 4.1 at 275 with water in the water pan because a WSM can and a Flower Pot can't. :heh:



Plated with some tater salad and doctored up Bush's baked beans. The beer selection was to honor Biggies Solstice party, oh fark it I was celebrating surviving Biggies Solstice party. Yes I know Moomingland is no where near LenexaOverlandFarkyamacallit but I don't trust that farker to borrow Gores transwhathamacallit. So :blah::blah::blah: my entry shot below. :becky:



Thanks for lookin :thumb:
 
Hi! This is my official WSM VS Flower Pot TD entry. :becky:

I was planning on entering on team flower pot but I'll be damned if Home Depot or anybody else in my area didn't have any pansies in stock. :mmph:
WTF apparently they don't come out until fall (yeah the equinox not the solstice). :tsk:

So I guess I'll just have to enter on team bullet.

This news didn't go over very well with a certain somebody...



Yeah as you can tell he's pissed. Well I kind of convinced him that he would be in charge of the important stuff, I mean really you cant have a cook without first lighting some briquettes. He didn't really buy it so I just flipped his top anyway. I mean really who's the boss here anyway?



I decided to do some ribs rubbed with Oakridge BBQ secret rib rub 4.1 at 275 with water in the water pan because a WSM can and a Flower Pot can't. :heh:



Plated with some tater salad and doctored up Bush's baked beans. The beer selection was to honor Biggies Solstice party, oh fark it I was celebrating surviving Biggies Solstice party. Yes I know Moomingland is no where near LenexaOverlandFarkyamacallit but I don't trust that farker to borrow Gores transwhathamacallit. So :blah::blah::blah: my entry shot below. :becky:



Thanks for lookin :thumb:

Hahahaha you have my vote and i cook on a Primo :biggrin1:
And your ribs need to be taste tested :wink: they look awesome:thumb:
 
Paul, loved your kamado/WSM story! :laugh: Ribs look great, I like the angle of them on the plate shot. Shows the crust and and the layers of meat on the ribs well, whole plate looks delicious. Congratulations for surviving Biggie's Solstice party. :wink:
 
Official entry to the "WSM/Bullet Smoker vs. Kamado"

Brethren,
My entry will be in the Kamado category.
Sorry, This thing is not ready to be retired to the garden. :boxing:

From what I have read my kamado is an original Imperial kamado made of black earthenware clay. These are extremely efficient cookers which started the whole ceramic egg phenomena. Due to its earthenware clay it keeps foods extremely moist & flavorful. I have dated this one to be over 50 years old. I bought it a few years ago off of craigslist for 240.00 dollars and fell in love with it. Is it better then a WSM/Bullet Smoker? Cant say really. :noidea: Ive never cooked out of one.

From this photo you can see that this smoker has handles on the lid. Those were put there so you could lift the lid off the smoker (before they made hinges for them). Some call them the ears. Many people like to take these old smokers, paint them, put temperature gauges on them as well as mount a lower vent down below. I prefer that old rustic look, leaving it in its original condition.
IMG_1181_zpsbc4d0dd4.jpg

This smoker originally came with a clay plug you could move in and out to adjust the air intake. (I don't have that piece).
This is my vent, a piece of cardboard wrapped in tinfoil. It works really well!:thumb:

IMG_1163_zpsdb619929.jpg

Lets get to the BBQ!
MaBBQ & I decided to have some of our "young friends" over we have known for a long time to share the BBQ with. :cool:

IMG_1211_zpsb83c36ab.jpg


Oh yea, Lets get to the BBQ. :roll:
Started with some hardwood briquettes from Trader Joes and a fist sized chunk of pecan.

IMG_1156_zps1470eac8.jpg


Rubbed down 3 racks of baby back Ribs the night before the cook. Two, with two different rubs from Simply Marvelous, and one with a special rub I make for MaBBQ.
IMG_1170_zps96f6c484.jpg


Meanwhile,
Time to prep some sides! Smoked some beans as well!

IMG_1184_zps787f9dc7.jpg


3 1/2 hours later, cooking at temps between 210 & 220….
Image_zps0f5d652a.jpg

YEP, They are ready!:becky:
IMG_1187_zpsd4b5e9b9.jpg

Juicy tender pull off the bone ribs in just 3 1/2 hours. No sauce needed!
IMG_1203_zps66502e65.jpg


Money shot please!!
IMG_1196_zpsac318732.jpg


Thanks for looking!
 
This Is My Official Entry in the WSM/Bullet Smoker vs. Kamado!" Throwdown

Meathenge: Using the Vertical Finishing Method on a Large USDA Choice Porterhouse


Yesterday, I was in the mood for a large porterhouse steak, so I headed to the Ralph's in Porter Ranch, which has some of the best beef within 25 miles. Wide selection of USDA Choice, and a very good selection of Prime as well.

Unfortunately, the porterhouse steaks they had in the meat section were too thin, so I asked the butcher if they had any bigger, and he said they'd be happy to cut one for me. I asked for 1.5 inches thick, and boy, did they cut up a beauty for me.

Here it is, unpacked:


DSC_2785_zps7470ede5.jpg



There's almost as much filet as there is strip! That's how I like my porterhouse steaks! There was, however, a pretty large line of fat outside the strip, so I decided to trim it off:


DSC_2786_zps76f0c7aa.jpg


I decided on a simple seasoning of seasoned pepper and seasoned salt:


DSC_2789_zpseff0b8ab.jpg



Then fired up the Kamado with a bunch of lump for a high heat cook:


DSC_2791_zps92d7837f.jpg



DSC_2793_zps8629ca07.jpg



For this cook, I didn't do my usual reverse sear, although I kept the bone side towards the fire at all times:


DSC_2794_zpsd7db4e18.jpg


After several minutes on each side, with an internal temp reading about 115, I employed a technique I use for any kind of chop or t-bone style cut, which is to place the meat bone side down over the hottest section of the grill. I find this very helpful in cooking the meat near the bone, which often comes out much more underdone than the rest of the meat. It always works great, plus it looks kinda cool:


DSC_2797_zps0b4f84ac.jpg



DSC_2798_zps95c38f75.jpg

Please use the above pic as my entry shot.



Sometimes with smaller cuts, or thinner ones, the meat won't stand upright, and in this situation, I'll just put a half section of brick on the grill to help prop it up.

After about two minutes standing upright, the meat was done, so I brought it inside and let it rest. I would like to point out that there is no way an WSM can cook a steak like my "flowerpot cooker". :mrgreen:

Meat resting:


DSC_2810_zps7301a5fb.jpg



Ten minutes later, I separated the filet and strip from the bone, and sliced it up:


CutSteak1_zpsb9607340.jpg


The Missus and I devoured our portions, and there wasn't a single scrap left!

I don't claim to have invented putting the chops upright at the end of a cook, as I'm sure some of you already do this, but for those who haven't tried it, I highly recommend it!
 
Gorgeous as usual Moose.
I do steakius erectus but I read about it on the web, food science.

Buccs,

I started doing this on lamb loin chops some years back, and it worked so well, I just started using it on all similar cuts. Kinda had the idea and ran with it.
 
Back
Top