You need a little bit of sweetness to balance out all that salt you put into and on it. Your brisket shouldn't taste like a steak. It should be a balanced piece of smoked beef.
But wouldn't that sweetness burn out on a judge after trying his third or fourth box?
I haven't judged before, would like to take the class and maybe give it a try some day. I thought I had read that a judge needs to learn to stick to one or two bites max, because they normally sample many items and can get full. (I could be wrong on that.)
Since I don't care for a sweet profile, I might not be a good candidate for judging...
Thoey, here in Tx you don't need to take a class to judge BBQ, unless it's KCBS of course. What people turn in around here can vary quite a bit, especially in ribs and chicken, however most around here turn in savory type of brisket, beefy, salt/peppery with just the right level of smoke. What separates the best from the others is nailing the tenderness and moisture and over all taste.