some insight to the burning question thread I hope.

Mo-Dave

Quintessential Chatty Farker
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
Location
Hurrican...
Trying to answer the question of dripping fat in a uds/cooker, creating an unfavorable odor and flavor for some. No doubt some do find it offensive for what ever reason but I have to rule out a low fire temp causing the fat to just smolder, creating this offensive condition to some.

If you move down to the part about the combustion process of wood and look at combustion points, in order for wood to make heat, then go down farther to smoke point of fats and grease you will see for even the lowest cooking temps say 200 to 300 of the degrees in the cooker, the fire would burn way above the combustion point of dripping fat plenty hot enough to burn the fat completely and not just smolder.

I am not calling anyone out on this in fact I understand completely, my youngest son would get violently ill to the point of puking if we cooked any form of sausage in the house no matter if it were boiled, baked or fried and no way could he eat it. But take that same meat and cook it outside on the grill and he loved it, go figure.

Wish I had one of those en-foray hand held gauges to check how hot a fire is at its surface is and know for sure. Any one want to do a test.

Anyway if my links works here you may find some other useful info to consider.
Dave










Wood and Combustion Heat Values

Firewood and combustion heat values - Pine, Elm, Hickory and many more species

Sponsored Links​
Type of wood - whether it is hardwood or softwood - burned in the combustion process is important for the heat value and the energy efficiency.
Hardwoods have less resin and burn slower and longer. Softwoods burn quickly. In addition the seasoned length influences on the fuel efficiency. Seasoning the wood refers to the allowed drying time before combustion.
Wood need to be dried at least 4 to 6 months before use.
Densities and heat values of some common wood species are indicated in the table below. Note that the volume of a stack of firewood varies considerably on whether or not it is split and how it is stacked. The moisture content also play a role - the values below are based on a average moisture content of 20%.
Wood Species Density of Dry Wood
(lb/ft3) Weight of Dry Cord
(lb/cord) Recoverable Heat Value of Cord (Dry Wood)
(millions Btu/cord) Heat Value of Cord (Green Wood)
(millions Btu/cord) Units needed to produce 1 Million (cord/Btu's) Apple 48.7 4,100 26.5 18.6 0.054 Ash, white 22.3
Aspen 27 2,290 14.7 10.3 0.097 Balsam Fir 26.3 2,240 14.3 10.0 0.10 Basswood 24.8 2,110 13.5 9.5 0.106 Beech 44.2 3,760 24 16.8 0.060 Birch 21.7 Black Ash 35.2 2,990 19.1 13.4 0.075 Black Spruce 29.2 2,480 15.9 11.1 0.090 Boxelder 32.9 2,800 17.9 12.5 0.080 Buckeye 13.4 Butternut 15.4 Catalpa 16.4 Cherry 36.7 3,120 20 14 0.071 Chestnut 12.9 Coffeetree 21.6 Cottonwood 24.8 2,110 13.5 9.5 0.106 Dogwood 27.0 Douglas Fir 26.4 East Hop hornbeam 50.2 4,270 27.3 19.1 0.052 Elm 35.9 3,050 19.5 13.7 0.073 Hackberry 38.2 3,250 20.8 14.6 0.069 Hemlock 29.2 2,480 15.9 11.1 0.090 Hickory 50.9 4,330 27.7 19.4 0.052 Ironwood 26.0 Jack Pine 31.4 2,670 17.1 12.0 0.084 Larch - Eastern 18.7 Locust 27.3 Lodgepole pine 19.3 Maple 21.6 Mulberry 25.8 Norway Pine 31.4 2,670 17.1 12.0 0.084 Osage Orange 32.9 Paper Birch 37.4 3,180 20.3 14.2 0.070 Pinon Pine 33.5 Ponderosa Pine 28 2,380 15.2 10.6 0.094 Redcedar - east 19.8 Red Oak 44.2 3,760 24 16.8 0.060 Red Maple 34.4 2,920 18.7 13.1 0.076 Spruce 16.0 Sucamore 19.5 Sugar Maple 44.2 3,760 24 16.8 0.060 Tamarack 38.2 3,250 20.8 14.6 0.069 Tanarack pine 21.2 Yellow Birch 43.4 3,690 23.6 16.5 0.061 Yellow pine 22.0 Walnut - black 21.5 White Ash 43.4 3,690 23.6 16.5 0.061 White Oak 47.2 4,010 25.7 18.0 0.056 White Pine 26.3 2,240 14.3 10.0 0.100 Willow 13.2

  • 1 ft (foot) = 0.3048 m
  • 1 lb = 0.4536 kg
  • 1 Btu (British thermal unit) = 1,055.06 J = 107.6 kpm = 2.931x10-4 kWh = 0.252 kcal = 778.16 ft lbf = 1.055x1010 ergs = 252 cal = 0.293 watt hour
Note that in the table above 1 cord = 85 ft3 is used to convert between the "Density" and "Weight of Cord" column. Be aware that the densities used for the wood species varies significantly. The densities used above is for natural dried wood where the average moisture content is approximately 20%.
Heat values of Cords with dry wood can be estimated by adding the green wood cords values with approximately 10%.
Recoverable heat values are calculated with a stove efficiency of approximately 65%.
The Combustion Process of Burning Wood


  1. Wood heats up to approximately 212 oF (100 oC) evaporating the moisture in it. There is no heating from the wood at this point
  2. Wood solids starts to break down converting the fuel gases (near 575 oF, 300 oC)
  3. From 575 oF to 1100 oF (300 - 600 oC ) the main energy in the wood is released when fuel vapors containing 40% to 60% of the energy burn
  4. After burning fuel vapors and evaporated the moisture, only charcoal remains burning at temperatures higher than 1100o F

  • TC = 5/9(TF - 32)
Sponsored Links​
Related Topics


  • Combustion - Boiler house topics - fuels like oil, gas, coal, wood - chimneys, safety valves, tanks - combustion efficiency
  • Heating - Heating systems - capacity and design of boilers, pipelines, heat exchangers, expansion systems and more
  • Material Properties - Material properties - density, heat capacity, viscosity and more - for gases, fluids and solids
Sponsored Links​
Related Documents






ToolBox ShortList
• Add this Page!


Search the ToolBox!
Translate this Page!! About Us!
Temperature

oC
oF

Length

m
km
in
ft
yards
miles
nautical miles

Volume

m3
liters
in3
ft3
us gal

Velocity

m/s
km/h
ft/min
ft/s
mph
knots

Pressure

Pa (N/m2)
bar
mm H2O
kg/cm2
psi
inches H2O

Flow

m3/s
m3/h
US gpm
cfm

Unit Converter
Scientific Calculator


Free Industry Magazines
cleardot.gif
Maintenance Technology

EDN

Test & Measurement World




Engineering News
printer.png
PrinterFriendly

ToolBox ShortList
• Add this Page!

Link to this Page!



Comparative properties of common cooking fats (per 100g)
Total Fat Saturated Fat Monounsaturated Fat Polyunsaturated Fat Smoke Point Vegetable Shortening (hydrogenated) 71g 23g 8g 37g 182°C (360°F) Sunflower oil 100g 11g 20g 69g 232°C (450°F) Soybean oil 100g 16g 23g 58g 232°C (450°F) Peanut oil 100g 17g 46g 32g 232°C (450°F) Olive oil 100g 14g 73g 11g 216°C (420°F) Lard 100g 39g 45g 11g 188°C (370°F) Suet 94g 52g 32g 3g 200°C (400°F) Butter 81g 51g 21g 3g 177°C (350°F)

Free Industry Magazines
cleardot.gif
Control

Product Design & Development

Pipeline & Gas Journal





ToolBox Short List

Difficult to find your favorite ToolBox page? Add links to your favorite pages in your own personal Short List!
Add this Page! • Delete the ShortList!

Engineering ToolBox - SketchUp Edition - Online 3D modeling!

Engineering ToolBox - SketchUp Edition - enabled for use with the amazing, fun and free Google SketchUp.

Search the ToolBox



poweredby_FFFFFF.gif

Custom Search



Translate the ToolBox

Arabic - Chinese (Simplified) - Chinese (Traditional) - Dutch - French - German - Italian - Japanese - Korean - Portuguese - Russian - Spanish


About the ToolBox

We appreciate any comments and tips on how to make The Engineering ToolBox a better information source. Please contact us by email

if You find any faults, inaccuracies, or otherwise unacceptable information.
The content in The Engineering ToolBox is copyrighted but can be used with NO WARRANTY or LIABILITY. Important information should always be double checked with alternative sources. All applicable national and local regulations and practices concerning this aspects must be strictly followed and adhered to.


Advertise in the ToolBox

If you want to promote your products or services in this site - please follow this link.
 
My only response can be..."if you say so."[/QUOTE

The links did not show up as they did on the sits and it makes it harder to follow, I apologize for that but it ant me saying so if you can believe everything you read.
Dave
 
  1. Wood heats up to approximately 212 oF (100 oC) evaporating the moisture in it. There is no heating from the wood at this point
  2. Wood solids starts to break down converting the fuel gases (near 575 oF, 300 oC)
  3. From 575 oF to 1100 oF (300 - 600 oC ) the main energy in the wood is released when fuel vapors containing 40% to 60% of the energy burn
  4. After burning fuel vapors and evaporated the moisture, only charcoal remains burning at temperatures higher than 1100o F
Lard 100g 39g 45g 11g 188°C (370°F)

Hope I made this a little clearer. As you can see lard burns at 370 degrees while most woods will be at 1100 degrees I am guessing surface temp, when at the charcoal stage so it should burn the drippings cleanly. My only guess is the small space inside a uds may increase the density of smoke from the fat. I chose lard because it is the only animal fat I see. You may have a different takeaway on this and that is fine, personally as I have said before I like the taste.

Next question if you don't like the taste and you are a CBJ how would you score taste?
Dave
 
Back
Top