9 Pro Tips For Making Brisket

I don't even know where to begin. :doh:

1. No, just no.

2. This just says to season properly. Great tip there: don't season improperly

3. Has anyone actually done a side by side taste test of mustard slather vs just putting the rub on? I have, and there is no discernible difference in taste or appearance.

4. I can't comment on this one, but I am suspicious of it.

5. No

6. A 185-190F flat?! Talk about shoe leather. And the old fat side up debate

7. Sounds good

8 and 9 would be labeled as crimes against brisket in these parts :biggrin1:

i've always wondered about that too. anytime i hear about the mustard the reason is to make the rub stick to the meat. wtf? i've never used a mustard slather and never had an issue with the rub not sticking to the meat
 
Wow! I thought I had read everything, but just when u think you have seen it all....

How about four easy steps for perfect brisket:

1. Buy brisket. Don't trim, don't mess with it, just make sure it is thawed and not frozen!
2. Season heavily with salt and pepper.
3. Cook brisket low and slow until it wiggles like jello (about 12-14 hours for a 16 lb. brisket)
4. Eat brisket.

All other steps are simply wasting time. Don't slather, don't inject, dont f*ck with it...just let it cook low and slow until wiggly like jello!

Not hard to do. And doesn't take 9 steps!

Actually it should be titled "brisket in just two steps" as step number 1 and 4 are kind of a given for pretty much everyone with common sense!
 
Wow! I thought I had read everything, but just when u think you have seen it all....

How about four easy steps for perfect brisket:

1. Buy brisket. Don't trim, don't mess with it, just make sure it is thawed and not frozen!
2. Season heavily with salt and pepper.
3. Cook brisket low and slow until it wiggles like jello (about 12-14 hours for a 16 lb. brisket)
4. Eat brisket.

All other steps are simply wasting time. Don't slather, don't inject, dont f*ck with it...just let it cook low and slow until wiggly like jello!

Not hard to do. And doesn't take 9 steps!

Actually it should be titled "brisket in just two steps" as step number 1 and 4 are kind of a given for pretty much everyone with common sense!

Yep! :thumb:
 
Dang! They are not even from Texas! Here's my Super Secret Brisket recipe!

2w1sgpi.jpg

Yeah you better slice it thinly. And here's a tip: have a 38 handy so you can swallow it as an aperitif.
 
In re: #7, who would chop up brisket and add lettuce and tomato and put it in a tortilla. A tortilla of any flavor...No, just no! Brisket isn't for lettuce, tomato or any flour or corn tortilla! That is just wrong. :doh:
 
Now hold on a second. A handful of brisket on a flour tortilla with a little cheddar and pico is a wonderous thing. Save the lettuce for a salad.

And if you "need" sauce, you might have did something wrong.
 
Figured this would be a great read for you guys that just think you have perfected the glorious chunk of cow. :tape:

They really seem to try and put Chris Lilly's quotes and advice out of context here, mixing it in with the author's own assertions.

Remember guys, ask your butcher for the flat cut and tell em to go ahead and trim it up for you! :shock:


http://www.mensjournal.com/food-drink/recipes/9-pro-tips-for-making-brisket-20150710


1. Trim the Fat
"Brisket is a large cut of beef that comes from the front, underside section of the cow. Because it can be up to 15 pounds, it gets divided into smaller portions. Always ask your butcher for the leaner flat cut that has less fat and connective tissue, which means fewer calories and it is not as tough. A 4 oz. serving of brisket is a complete protein (translation: it can actually support weight loss!) and provides half your daily protein needs. It is lower in fat than other cuts of beef and contains linoleic acid, which can help prevent diabetes, high cholesterol and cancer cell growth. It's also loaded with B vitamins (actually 8 times the B12 found in a skinless chicken breast), riboflavin, niacin, zinc, iron and selenium," says Executive Chef and Founder of PALETA, Kelly Boyer.
Save time in the kitchen and have your butcher trim most of the fat from the meat before you prepare it. Alternatively, says Boyer, it's very easy to remove the excess fat after you cook the meat and before you serve it. This method will produce a slightly higher calorie serving, but it will fall away easily from the meat with a knife and fork.

2. Season Well
"Season properly! The biggest mistake made when cooking large cuts of meat is to not season the food correctly in the beginning stages. This is critical and where you build all your initial flavor," says Michael Dussault, executive chef at The International in Bolton, MA. and recent contestant on the current season of Hell's Kitchen with Gordon Ramsay on FOX.

3. The Rub
A slather of yellow mustard will help the seasoning to adhere to the meat while adding a complementary, slightly acidic flavor to the meat, says Pitmaster Chris Lilly on behalf of Kingsford Charcoal. "A simple go-to brisket rub starts with a 50/50 mix of kosher salt and coarse ground black pepper. Add garlic powder to taste," says Lilly. The addition of oak or hickory chunks to charcoal provides a flavor combination that complements the natural beef flavor, says Lilly.

4. The 'Other' Beef
Consider bison brisket for an even healthier option, says Boyer. "Bison has a stronger flavor than beef, but is even leaner with 2.5 grams of fat in a 3.5oz serving, compared to choice beef which has just over 18 grams of fat. Cholesterol levels are similar, but the same 3.5oz serving of bison has 143 calories compared to 283 in choice beef. Comparatively, bison has more iron and vitamin B12. Bison are also grass fed, allowed to roam, and are free of hormones and antibiotics. Beef standards and processing methods vary widely, but it depends on the company as to how the cattle and meat are handled," says Boyer.

5. Sear the Brisket Off
Always season heavily and get a nice golden sear and crust on your brisket to promote flavor, browning, color and to allow the meat to become as tender as possible without falling apart, says Dussault. This is an important stage and where another layer of flavor is built where the sear adds additional colors, flavors and aromatics that cannot be reproduced.

6. Pay Attention to Fire
Cooking brisket fat side up insures maximum fat caramelization and flavor, says Lilly. Because all briskets have different thicknesses, cooking time is going to vary. "A 12-pound brisket will take close to 10 hours to cook at 225°F over indirect heat. The most important detail is what temperature to pull it at; the lean flat is ready at 185-190 °F and the fatty point is perfect at 200-205°F," says Lilly. Let the brisket rest for a minimum of 30 minutes before slicing. Never slice brisket with the grain, says Lilly. Always cut perpendicular to the grain to achieve maximum tenderness.

7. South of the Border
"I never met a taco I didn't like and brisket is no exception. I use heart healthy corn or whole grain tortillas, fresh tomatillo salsa, chopped lettuce, and sliced bell peppers. Chop the cooked brisket into small pieces, toss with a little adobo sauce from canned chipotle chilies and compose a taco using your favorite toppings," says Boyer. Dust with a little queso and fresh cilantro and serve. Save some carb calories and replace the tortillas with chopped super greens for a lighter Mexican salad.

8. Thai Inspired
"I love transforming brisket by tossing thinly sliced pieces with Thai flavors like lime, fish sauce, and Sriracha to dress the beef. Heap the flavored brisket onto a whole butter lettuce leaf, cover with grated carrot, chopped peanuts, fresh cilantro, and minced jalapeno and red onion," says Boyer. Squeeze some fresh lime on top and dive in.

9. Backyard BBQ
"I love to use seasonal summer ingredients like cherries to make a homemade bbq sauce (easier than you think and so worth it!). You can cook your brisket for several hours covered on a low temp on your grill or in your oven. When it's done, give your brisket on a nice char on a high heat grill on all sides and then baste in your bbq sauce. We like to shred the sweet and smoky bbq brisket and serve it on miniature whole-grain buns, topped with a cool, refreshing vegetable slaw for mini sliders," says Boyer.


Nothing funnier than folks who may very well be experts within the confines of their own specialty giving sound bites simply in an attempt to be relevant in areas completely outside of their comfort zone.

1. I have a hard time believing anyone could ever use her guidance to make a good brisket. Sounds like regurgitation of something someone else said. Is anyone doing a 8-12 Que really concerned about calorie count?

2. Duh......

3. One can use mustard, olive oil, or nothing.

4. Never had it. But, I'm guessing one needs to be very careful not to overcook due to the leanness of the meat.

5. Searing to get brownness? I figured a few hours of smoke would give one all the brownness they need.

6. Pay attention to the fire? Really, I thought you had to do was build a fire, guess at what temp you think your cooker will average, consult a meat chart, throw the brisket on then walk away and come back in hh:mm:ss and retrieve a perfect brisket.

7. I could see wrapping up some leftovers in a flour tortilla with some chopped onions, tomatoes, lettuce and salsa.

8. ""I love transforming brisket by tossing thinly sliced pieces with Thai flavors like lime, fish sauce, and Sriracha to dress the beef."

Translation: "I can't cook brisket worth a chit, so I have to disguise it."

9. I'm thinking if one cooks a brisket over low heat on a backyard pit until it's done it will have a nice char unless it was wrapped in foil form the beginning. If so, then why cook it outdoors to begin with?
 
Glad I read the rest of the thread. I was thinking this is coming from a brisket pro but it all all seems so strange and maybe even wrong. I don't do any of it and i love my brisket. The Bretheran set me straight!
 
Now hold on a second. A handful of brisket on a flour tortilla with a little cheddar and pico is a wonderous thing. Save the lettuce for a salad.

And if you "need" sauce, you might have did something wrong.


Maybe the day after, I could see that. But right off the smoker?
 
Typically, when I cook brisket there is know leftovers so I have no reason to put it on Tortillas or a bed of lettuce!!!
 
If you read his book, it is clear Men's Health is quoating him out of context. His recipies are all for whole packers and he even has a recipe praising burnt ends--it's obviously Men's Health that is so afraid of fat and not Lilley
 
Now hold on a second. A handful of brisket on a flour tortilla with a little cheddar and pico is a wonderous thing. Save the lettuce for a salad.

And if you "need" sauce, you might have did something wrong.
Amen Brotha', a little of the point wrapped in a flour tortilla with some salsa or pico is my FAVORITE way to eat brisket!:thumb:
 
Back
Top