Smoker Choices

backdraftbbq

Full Fledged Farker
Joined
Sep 8, 2015
Location
Stamford...
I currently have one Rec Tec pellet smoker and I'm very happy with it. I've just started competing and I've quickly realized that I need more than one smoker. There are so many choices out there and I'd appreciate everyone's input.
 
1st welcome to our sport known as competition BBQ. 2nd you are wrong when you say you need more than 1 smoker. You may just not have the right smoker for you yet or you may mean you would like to cook at 2 different temps at the same time with different woods.

My advice is really take your time research cookers, get a budget and start saving (dont get a lone for a smoker). Also I advice to check the sale section here on the forum. I would much rather get an awesome used cooker than a new not so good settle for cooker.

Just my 2 cents and welcome to you again.
 
If you provided some details on what you would like in a cooker it would help us give you suggestions.

Some examples

Budget?
Size?
Pellet? Charcoal? Stick Burner?
Insulated? Non Insulated?
 
whiz-nit hit the nail on the head......my personal opinion, i think you can manage cooking all 4 meats for a comp with one smoker....you just have to map out your time lines and hit your marks.

as for a recommendation......that's sort of like recommending a car for you to buy.....it really depends on what you are looking for in a smoker and what you plan to be cooking and how much you plan to be cooking outside of comps.

i loved the whole idea of the water cookers offered by Myron Mixon Smokers and I chose to go that route with a MMS-48. it's a perfect smoker for me, fits great in my enclosed trailer and allows me to room within the trailer to pack everything else I need when traveling.

However, with that said, let me also say, that my partner has a homemade smoker that he made out of a old water tank off of a concrete truck and it does fantastic. the only issue is that it isn't insulated.......but the point is whether you want to spend $5000 or make your own or buy something much cheaper, there are a ton of great options available to you. I would highly suggest you research the different types and strategies used to cook with them and choose the one that makes the most sense to you. i will say that having a smoker be insulated is a very important thing, because it allows you to cook in cooler weather or the rain without a great deal of difficulty.

however, in the end, it's all about learning your smoker and once you do, no matter who made it, you will be able to turn out some great food.
 
Thank you all for your input. Being in the Northeast, an insulated smoker would be great. My competition season would run from the end of April to mid October. I would also use the smoker between comps for cooking at home. I've started to look at Yoder, Stumps and Humphreys. I don't mind investing money into a quality smoker. I'm starting to learn if I time everything properly I can use one smoker. Mine fell short when I did the people's choice comp and I had to cook 15 racks of baby backs and 40# of jumbo wings, even with a custom upper grill that I had made.
 
... I've just started competing and I've quickly realized that I need more than one smoker. ...
I agree with Shiz-Nit. When my team travels to the Mid Atlantic area to compete, we have only a single 22" WSM staged in PA. You might have a timeline/schedule challenge instead of a cooker capacity challenge.

If you firm up your schedule and holding methods first, then increase capacity, you will probably be better off in the long run.
 
Whatever you do get an insulated smoker. Kamados are nice but lack capacity so multiple would be necessary. A nice insulated cabinet smoker would fix that. Just saying if you can afford it then look at an insulated cabinet smoker.
 
Thank you all for your input. Being in the Northeast, an insulated smoker would be great. My competition season would run from the end of April to mid October. I would also use the smoker between comps for cooking at home. I've started to look at Yoder, Stumps and Humphreys. I don't mind investing money into a quality smoker. I'm starting to learn if I time everything properly I can use one smoker. Mine fell short when I did the people's choice comp and I had to cook 15 racks of baby backs and 40# of jumbo wings, even with a custom upper grill that I had made.

Living in the Northeast also, I would recommend a Humphrey's, they are built for the cooler temps we have up here!!! They make all different sizes, but if you are looking for one cooker for everything, I would go with the Humphrey's Qubed pint plus, it is heavy, but it can hold two(2) full pans on each cooking grate, and you could easily do a full contest plus people choice on this cooker. The charcoal pan will hold a 20# bag of charcoal!!! and once they get to temp the recovery time after opening the door is super quick, like 5 minutes tops!!!! check out their website. http://www.humphreysbbq.com/
 
I appreciate all of your input. Right now I'm trying to get the funding so that I can purchase a smoker and trailer. I've been looking at the Humphrey's and Stumps. Anyone have experience with Spicewine?
 
Whatever you do get an insulated smoker. Kamados are nice but lack capacity so multiple would be necessary. A nice insulated cabinet smoker would fix that. Just saying if you can afford it then look at an insulated cabinet smoker.
I do not and have not ever owned an insulated smoker nor do I feel I need one. There are many other things that are much further up the list of must haves other than insulation.
 
I do not and have not ever owned an insulated smoker nor do I feel I need one. There are many other things that are much further up the list of must haves other than insulation.

I've heard that the Cookshack pellet smokers are insulated. While they might not be the "BEST", I've heard that they have won all the world championship competitions. :doh:
 
I've heard that the Cookshack pellet smokers are insulated. While they might not be the "BEST", I've heard that they have won all the world championship competitions. :doh:
and when some of the others have been on the market as long as the cookshacks have they probably will have won them all too.
 
out of curiosity what are those must haves that far exceed the need of insulation in your opinion?
Even temps throughout the cooker would be #1. Insulation is not even a desirable. Most of my competition season is in temps between 80-100 degrees.
 
Back
Top