I just received my 4th batch of pellets and in my 2* this is what I've found:
Bear Mountain (Hickory)
Smoke: Moderate
Aroma while burning: Moderate
Flavor on food: A bit more than slight
Firepot/Flameouts: 1 - likely due to unclean firepot
Lumberjack (100% Hickory)
Smoke: Heavy
Aroma while burning: Heavy (dare I say like a stickburner)
Flavor on food: So far the best flavor from pellets I've tasted
Firepot/Flameouts: Yes (3). If the pot wasn't clean it'd flameout. If you changed the temp from low and slow to a more moderate heat it'd flame out.
CookinPellets (Perfect Mix)
Smoke: Wispy
Aroma while burning: light at best
Firepot: Bulletproof never bothered to clean it
Flavor on food: Blink and you'll miss it
Firepot/Flameouts: 0. Never bothered to clean the firepot.
Also: Seemed to take longer to reach temps, didn't like going 375+
Lumberjack (Comp Blend): TBD
Finishing up the last of the CookinPellets with a ~8lb boneless shoulder that I injected with some Dijon, cayenne, yardbird, apple cider vinegar and apple cider.