Charny
Full Fledged Farker
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2017
- Location
- Floating on the Great Lakes
I recently picked up a 22" WSM and need to lay in a supply of charcoal while the sales are on - limited as they are. I'd appreciate opinions on the following options (any I'm missing?):
For free shipping at $35 (not in my local store):
Walmart has B&B Charcoal 17.6 lb All-Natural Oak Charcoal Briquets, $9.97 for 17.6 lbs ($.57/lbs)
Walmart has Cowboy Hardwood Charcoal Briquets, 20 Pounds Each for $17.92 ($.45/lbs)
(the price on that one sometimes changes in my cart and tries to go up to $27.59. That is very frustrating BS - I was about to place an order this AM). And hopefully not too busted from shipping.
Costco:
I tried Kingsford Pro in my kettle. It's good - low ash, but burns a bit quick. The Costco sale goes through Jul 2 and is 2X 18 lbs bags for 24.69, minus $6.20 = $18.49. That's $.514/lbs.
"Cowboy Oak and Hickory" lump, 34 lbs, for $26. That's .764. A bit pricey, but it is not on sale.
Royal oak is an option, but my past experience is it makes a lot of ash that clogs grates.
Some prefer the B&B, others say it stinks. I also read duraflame bought them a couple years back, so maybe it has changed. Most say they prefer the consistency of briquettes in the WSM, while a few prefer the cleaner flavor of lump.
I know many swear by the KBB. Local sales aren't any less expensive than the KP.
The cowboy briqs look like the sweet spot.
Thanks!
For free shipping at $35 (not in my local store):
Walmart has B&B Charcoal 17.6 lb All-Natural Oak Charcoal Briquets, $9.97 for 17.6 lbs ($.57/lbs)
Walmart has Cowboy Hardwood Charcoal Briquets, 20 Pounds Each for $17.92 ($.45/lbs)
(the price on that one sometimes changes in my cart and tries to go up to $27.59. That is very frustrating BS - I was about to place an order this AM). And hopefully not too busted from shipping.
Costco:
I tried Kingsford Pro in my kettle. It's good - low ash, but burns a bit quick. The Costco sale goes through Jul 2 and is 2X 18 lbs bags for 24.69, minus $6.20 = $18.49. That's $.514/lbs.
"Cowboy Oak and Hickory" lump, 34 lbs, for $26. That's .764. A bit pricey, but it is not on sale.
Royal oak is an option, but my past experience is it makes a lot of ash that clogs grates.
Some prefer the B&B, others say it stinks. I also read duraflame bought them a couple years back, so maybe it has changed. Most say they prefer the consistency of briquettes in the WSM, while a few prefer the cleaner flavor of lump.
I know many swear by the KBB. Local sales aren't any less expensive than the KP.
The cowboy briqs look like the sweet spot.
Thanks!
