Derussi
Is lookin for wood to cook with.
- Joined
- Dec 11, 2012
- Location
- Crossvil...
I have the same issue from Huntsville scores for both pro & backyard and only judged pro.
Yeah I saw some impossible scores that I knew were inaccurate.
Showed me giving a 1 in appearance . Which never happened .
Guess it is all hand entered so mistakes happen
I wish to thank KCBS for making my scores available to me. Has been a long time coming. Have downloaded and analyzed them. It told me what I wanted to know. I am a happy camper.
Looking forward to being seated by my Running Table Average !
So what did you learn? You scored lower than others at your table so now you must score higher to match them? Too high, so score lower?
Why would you not just score each entry as presented to you per KCBS training and procedures and not worry about the rest of the table...
Ed
You sneaked into Chili's kitchen?I told you not to boil your ribs, but did you listen to me? Noooooooooo...
So what did you learn? You scored lower than others at your table so now you must score higher to match them? Too high, so score lower?
Why would you not just score each entry as presented to you per KCBS training and procedures and not worry about the rest of the table.
What the others at your table are doing must not impact your scores at all.
Or were you just being sourcastic???
Ed
So what did you learn? You scored lower than others at your table so now you must score higher to match them? Too high, so score lower?
Why would you not just score each entry as presented to you per KCBS training and procedures and not worry about the rest of the table.
What the others at your table are doing must not impact your scores at all.
Or were you just being sourcastic???
Ed
... I still think the person deciding who gets to judge should be provided with this information.
The issue of why it was only up briefly was brought up at an event this weekend in DC. THe answer that was given was that the scores were somehow out of sync....
So the result will be some judges will never get selected.I agree 100%. It is no different than looking at a person's résumé before you hire them for a job.
Yes there are a lot of 7,8 and 9 scores. There are also a lot of entries that are extremely similar. Maybe all those cooking classes are a factor. They are 1) raising the overall quality and 2) making the entries more alike. Of course the scores are going to be clustered at 7,8,9. Believe me when I get an entry that deserves a 4, I write down a 4, with a comment card of course.
OH!! GASP!!! you don't factor in the cost to compete and just give a 7 as that will put the team out of the running?? You know '7' is the lowest score you are suppose to give :icon_smile_tongue: