Chicken box

midwest_kc · Jul 28, 2014

So this weekend, we tried something different. I have always thought that legs done right are the best piece of chicken, and that the judges would enjoy them as well. So we cooked them as well as thighs. Same recipe, just different pieces of meat (turned the legs into lollipops too).

I was really happy with how they came out, but feel like they could look better. I put foil over the bones, up until saucing. When I sauced them, I took the foil off and dunked them all in sauce, then back on the pit to set. I feel like this may not have been the best idea, so I'll have to try it with the foil on the whole time at home sometime.

Anyways - what do you think of this box? FYI, we did fill in that front middle part of the parsley after this pic, so while it's low now, it wasn't at turn it in. I'm curious as to how you all would judge it.

bbq.tom · Jul 28, 2014

At first glance I would give this box an 8, as it looks pretty dad-gum good, but there are just a couple things that could be better. The stripes (grill marks) are showing on some but not others, kinda looks a wee bit dry (maybe not in person, but does in this photo). Other than that I like this box! I might have given it a 9 in person.

tdwalker · Jul 28, 2014

I'm with bbq.tom, I would give this an 8. Looks real good, but sauce is uneven.

DawgPhan · Jul 28, 2014

It just looks like average bbq chicken to me.

7 to be generous.

that low spot of parsley wouldnt even come into the equation.

MikeJ65 · Jul 28, 2014

If it was my box, I would have expected mostly 8's, but a 7 or two wouldn't have shocked me.

DR · Jul 28, 2014

I like it. Probably going to be an 8 for me.

midwest_kc · Jul 28, 2014

Any opinions on the bones? Are they fine, or do you think keeping them foiled the whole time would be better?

bbq.tom · Jul 28, 2014

FWIW... These bones are fine just the way they are for me.

DawgPhan · Jul 28, 2014

I think that the bones look fine. The color of the chicken doesnt appeal to me. The layout seems off.

tduffy · Jul 28, 2014

It would be a 7 or 8. Honestly lolipop chicken does not look very appetizing to me. regular drumsticks i think look more appealing.

SOB · Jul 28, 2014

The layout throws it of for me. Solid 8. In person I think this could be a 9 if all chicken is the same way. Maybe with all bones slight crossed making three Xs right down the middle.

bbq.tom · Jul 28, 2014

SOB said:
Maybe with all bones slight crossed making three Xs right down the middle.

Be careful with 3 Xs as someone might claim that it is a marked box. I was TC at a table when this happened and had to get the REP to make a ruling on the box. The REP discussed it with another REP and finally decided it wasn't marked. Just letting you know that some might question that arrangement.

midwest_kc · Jul 28, 2014

Thanks for all the input (and any that might come after this). I sense that I was right, in thinking that they looked good, not great, overall. The funny thing is, that I got all 9s on my appearance, and got our highest finish ever in chicken. I know I probably should just take it and roll with it, as it worked, obviously, but I can't help but think that I can't just do the same thing next time out.

They tasted great, by the way. I had some skin issues I'm guessing, as I got 2 7s on tenderness, but taste was all 9s and 8s too.

DR · Jul 28, 2014

midwest_kc said:
Any opinions on the bones? Are they fine, or do you think keeping them foiled the whole time would be better?

Bones are ok to me also. I actually like the color on them instead of a nasty white bone.

Burnt at Both Endz · Jul 28, 2014

They look appetizing to me, I could see 9's from them. Bones look fine/natural.

Butt Rubb'n BBQ · Jul 29, 2014

The chicken looks good maybe a little flat not glossy. I would have left the foil on the entire time. It gives you a cleaner finish and some color contrast. I applaud you for turning in lollypops but I would never turn in anything other than a bone in thigh because that's mostly what they expect to see around here. Scared say your scared.

midwest_kc · Jul 29, 2014

Yeah, we cooked both, so that we could pick the better product, and quite frankly the legs were better. The 2 we tried didn't have any skin issues, though my turn in ones apparently did - so I need to fix this, but I think next time out we'll only cook these.

ModelMaker · Jul 29, 2014

DawgPhan said:
It just looks like average bbq chicken to me.

7 to be generous.

that low spot of parsley wouldnt even come into the equation.

Just to make it clear, low spot, high spot it makes absolutely no difference.
"Once garnish is termed to be legal, it plays no further role in appearance scoring"
Ed

Chicken box

midwest_kc

is one Smokin' Farker

bbq.tom

is Blowin Smoke!

tdwalker

Full Fledged Farker

DawgPhan

is Blowin Smoke!

MikeJ65

is one Smokin' Farker

DR

Take a breath!

midwest_kc

is one Smokin' Farker

bbq.tom

is Blowin Smoke!

DawgPhan

is Blowin Smoke!

tduffy

is Blowin Smoke!

SOB

Full Fledged Farker

bbq.tom

is Blowin Smoke!

midwest_kc

is one Smokin' Farker

DR

Take a breath!

Burnt at Both Endz

Babbling Farker

Butt Rubb'n BBQ

Take a breath!

midwest_kc

is one Smokin' Farker

ModelMaker

Quintessential Chatty Farker

Similar threads