Discussion Thread -> "Chuck Primal" Throwdown (Entries and Quality ON TOPIC *CLEAN* Discussion Only)

Moose

somebody shut me the fark up.

Batch Image
Joined
Oct 12, 2008
Messages
14,353
Reaction score
64,804
Points
113
Location
Gallatin, TN
Our new TD category is...

"Chuck Primal"

021_zpsc1b1feb2.jpg


This was Haastyle's winning entry in the Feb. 1014 "Chucky Challenge" TD.


As chosen by sliding_billy for winning the "Turkey" Throwdown.

CATEGORY DESCRIPTION - READ BEFORE ENTERING

sliding_billy said:
For the next Throwdown, I choose Chuck Primal. Cook anything you want from the beef chuck primal (ribs, roast, steaks... sliced, pulled, whole) as long as it conforms to standard Throwdown rules. Couldn't be any simpler. :laugh:


You may submit entries that are cooked from Friday 12/12 through the entry submission deadline of 12 p.m. Central US Time on Monday 12/22/14.

Entry pictures must be submitted by 12 p.m. Central US Time on Monday 12/22.

Click here to READ THE RULES for the BBQ Brethren Throwdown...

Click here to READ THE RULES for the BBQ Brethren Throwdown...

The ENTRY and VOTE threads will follow Q-Talk rules, meaning QUALITY ON-TOPIC discussion of the category or entries only, please. Discussion is encouraged to take place in the DISCUSSION THREAD, but if you want a recipe, or are looking for details or have QUALITY ON-TOPIC comments to make about an entry or the category you can make them in the ENTRY or VOTE thread. Non-quality posts that are made here will be deleted and the offending member will be asked why they couldn't just post in the DISCUSSION thread instead, and in extreme cases or repeat offenders, disciplinary action WILL happen.


Best of luck and even better eats to all!
 
Last edited:
Please accept this as my entry into the "chuck primal" TD.

This was my first chuck roast that I've smoked. Had a hankerin' for some peppers n onions,so I sliced some up and put them on the grill. As I was going thru the fridge getting the pepper and onion,I found some carrots. Had the bright idea to slice them, and put them in another foil packet with some butter,sugar,and brown sugar. Other than the mac n cheese and bread,everything on here was done on my WSM. I don't even like carrots, but MAN these were good.
As for the chuckie,being my first,it turned out great!!



Thanks for looking and considering my entry.
 
This is an official entry...

Bovine Bold Pot Roast

I picked up a 3.5 lb bone-in chuck roast and seasoned it liberally with Bovine Bold from Plowboys BBQ and let it rest to give the rub a chance to rehydrate.

16022632421_6d10ed38fe_c.jpg


While it was resting I cut up some carrots, celery, onions and red skin potatoes and put them in the Crock Pot along with some garlic and more Bovine Bold...

16024570145_cc4b6a568a_c.jpg


Then I tossed the chuck onto the grill to give it some nice crosshatching and flavor...

15402314994_9a3e18f1b9_c.jpg


15838826847_7f9c50fbf6_c.jpg


Once that was done it went into the Crock Pot (tight fit) along with some red wine and beef stock...

15837156958_163e9059c5_c.jpg


8 hours later...

16022632631_000aaf71be_c.jpg


16022632691_8806e1af1e_c.jpg

Please use this picture ^^^^ for my entry

This is my favorite way of doing a pot roast. Bovine Bold gives it a little heat and you can taste the flavor from the grill.
 
Please accept this as my official entry to the "Chuck Primal" Throwdown.

The players...

CAB chuckie and Oakridge Black Ops

C47C6F72-458E-4B48-BF2B-CEAE6ACED161.jpg


Rubbed and sitting alongside the ham I did today...

A8ABCEE5-1E96-454D-BCE0-CF7B8685C15E.jpg


Earl crankin' along with some hickory, pecan and bradford pear...

DEFE749C-FF50-4221-B197-79F7EC4F2C8F.jpg


767A575F-4D62-4616-BDFA-412123E8A20F.jpg


A few hours in...

26AD0849-732C-4033-BC88-FA9003D58AA3.jpg


Getting ready to wrap. Braising this with some Real Ale Coffee Porter...

B947F39E-0F45-411A-B331-C9A17027C111.jpg


Wrapped it up and braised it for a couple hours until it was pull tender and pulled it and placed it back in Earl to reduce the liquid.

837BCB09-2B92-49BA-A6A6-A26575314D70.jpg


Here it is ready to get inside some tacos!

9E6EC9CB-7789-474B-8A46-D7DFEE1479D4.jpg


Enjoyed the meal with a Kentucky Ale.

00541248-D838-494D-B1AB-F5BA569E3A14.jpg


Tacos with pico, guac, pepper jack cheese, and chopped cliantro! Killer!!!

546F1D6B-C1D9-4F47-8BB0-603D68559DF9.jpg


061DB844-6E80-45D4-A50E-54ED362C0EE0.jpg


Entry shot is above.
 
Official entry...

Seasoned up a hunk of chuck with some S&P, and tossed it on the kettle with a couple of onions. used some RO briqs, mesquite, and apple
E28891D7-546F-4268-A12E-D8600483C9E8_zps6867a2gt.jpg

Let it go for a while to pick up some color and flavor
D63C8AC8-D32B-4961-BA13-CBA54EB54B35_zpskjhdrrgf.jpg

meanwhile, rehydrated some guajillos and chipotles
3DA2E827-CD4E-4275-B92D-95AAD3160FB2_zpseoutjzeu.jpg

Chopped up the chuck, and the onions, tossed them into the crotch pot with some diced tomatoes, the peppers (blended up and pushed through a metal strainer), some beans, and some chile seasoning (chile powder, cumin, pepper, cayenne, etc)
D013DB99-EB0B-45FC-84B1-06AC81ECD1E2_zps2sdnmjes.jpg

Let that go all day while I did some painting, and got some sleep. Served up with some shredded cheddar...ended up looking a little somethin' like this
319F89FD-17E2-4883-B59F-507FEBA879E0_zpsxrrazyju.jpg

entry pic, please:
BB4A08C6-E2E7-40AA-BC51-4B5B09940D1E_zpsgdclw8or.jpg
 
Wow...all that looks great! I don't stand a chance hahaha
 
So last weekend I cooked a bunch of chuck, and then I saw that there is a chuck throwdown going on. Score! I haven't been able to do any throwdowns lately.

I did 2 chuck roasts, a bit over 7 lbs total. Smoked with pecan, then in a foiled pan with onions, wine, and broth, then pulled.

Cook thread: http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/showthread.php?t=202020

Please use this as my entry picture:

1983.jpg
 
So last weekend I cooked a bunch of chuck, and then I saw that there is a chuck throwdown going on. Score! I haven't been able to do any throwdowns lately.

I did 2 chuck roasts, a bit over 7 lbs total. Smoked with pecan, then in a foiled pan with onions, wine, and broth, then pulled.

Cook thread: http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/showthread.php?t=202020

Please use this as my entry picture:

1983.jpg
Sure is nice when the stars unknowingly align like that!!! Thanks for the great looking entry!
 
Official entry... I was originally going to do this as a clod TD, but I thought it might end up with me competing against myself. It worked out good doing chuck primal since technically I didn't do a clod. The day I was going to buy the clod, I saw Market Street had CAB chuck shoulder on sale for $3.50 /lb, the same price that RD charges for clod. (basically the same part of the shoulder as clod but cut and marketed differently). I talked to the meat manager, and he agreed to custom butcher me a couple of 8 pound roasts. So for the same price as the ~16 pound clod I would have had to buy I got a higher grade of meat, no sinew and someone else to do the butchering (I would have cut it into two pieces anyways). One for the TD, and one for the freezer... 12 hours on the nose cook time. Mostly around 240, but a bit hotter while in the butcher paper. Pooling pic noted in caption.


Nice marbling. The other one is a little bit larger and more uniformly square, but this one was still very nice. Dry aged in the fridge for 72 hours.


Rubbed with my regular brisket home brew.


167 degrees internal, and the color is perfect. About to be wrapped in butcher paper.


All done. Probing nicely at 192 degrees.


30 minute rest in the paper.


Good mix of lean and fatty.


But who doesn't like fatty better? Please use this as my pooling pic.


Saving some for later, so separated a chunk at the fat line.
 
Last edited:
I've decided Old School. Seriously New Braunfels Black Diamond with HICKORY. Concession stand time. I'll be back with an entry soon-or later!!

New Braunfels Black Diamond coming to a throw down near you
16adams_1_zpsce1fdf5f.jpg


Seasoned one side PBYardbird other side Coopers
16adams_2_zps58391c04.jpg


I've decided on Bavarian Chuck roast.
16adams_3_zps658a7c3d.jpg


Please accept this photo as official entry in Primal Chuck Throwdown. Bavarian Chuck Roast. 4-5 hours hickory smoke, into crock with sour kraut, onions, sour cream and beef broth. Served with garlic cheese biscuits and garlic mashed potatoes.

16adams_4_zps66b87ecf.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top