I just found this thread and voted. I should have read before voting since I also forgot to count the turkey fryer burner as "other".
I noticed that with my Kamado purchase, I now have the top four and for some reason I feel like I should get a bullet type to round out the top five. Not that I would have any reason to use it, but I also have no reason to use the gas grill either.
As for the gasser, I have one that has never gotten much use, and its main purposes are to block a bad piece of deck railing that will be replaced soon and to store things under its cover. I am thinking by August it will be given away and I can't imagine ever missing it. With the gas gear I have indoors, when I don't want to light wood or charcoal I have other (better) gas alternatives, but I can see why many others would want to keep one around despite also owning "better" smokers and grills.
Finally, I have a griddle and was tempted to check the box, but mine is indoors so I guess it doesn't count. Either way, I think they are a great tool and it is good to see their popularity in these virtual parts.
Thanks for putting this poll together, it was very informative.