COS
is one Smokin' Farker
People at your house eating your food will always sugar coat their opinions about the food. The truest and best indicators of the food being good are;
Did you see any food left on their plates?
Did folks go back for seconds or even thirds?
That said from where I'm sitting your first brisket looks as good or better than many that I have seen posted from the "pros". It dang sure looks better than any that I have done. Great job!
This here is what I do also with family. You know they will sugar coat it to some degree. I always look around to see how much they are eating.
I forgot to mention also, I'm barely hungry to eat anything after a long cook. One party I didn't eat anything expect to taste. After everybody left just had some kind of pizza rolls. There was even a thread about it on here awhile back.