Sliced Pork Rather Than Pulled

jpalaska · Mar 17, 2014

I know that what I'm about to say is heresy in my newly adopted North Carolina. But, I'm just not that crazy about pulled or shredded meats.
As you probably know, BBQed Boston Butt is the 'go to' meat in this neck of the woods.

I think I'd prefer trying to cook a shoulder for slicing instead of pulling.
Would I want to cook it less time in the WSM than if I was cooking it for pulling? Would a chunk of shoulder be better for slicing than a whole 8-10 lb shoulder?

thanks,
JP

Garrett · Mar 17, 2014

I always cook to be able to pull it, but if I wanted slices I would try cooking to an IT between 180 and 190. That would just be me guessing cause you wouldn't want it to be probe tender to make slices.

pmad · Mar 17, 2014

I had sliced at Arthur Bryant's in KC.
It was fantastic.

Jaskew82 · Mar 17, 2014

I purchase a small section of a boston butt from my local grocer this weekend. It was actually the money muscle section with a bit more from behind it. All dark meat and was fantastic. I cut a pocket into it, stuffed it with some precooked apples, onion, bread, etc.

I thew it on the BGE @ around 375 deg and cooked 90 minutes when the temp hit around 165 internal. I let it rest and sliced it at around 1/4 thick. It was very good.

Sliced pork is excellent - nothing to be ashamed of. I recommend cooking to around 160 degrees.

jpalaska · Mar 17, 2014

Garrett said:
I always cook to be able to pull it, but if I wanted slices I would try cooking to an IT between 180 and 190. That would just be me guessing cause you wouldn't want it to be probe tender to make slices.

Thanks Garret,
What is 'probe tender'?

JP

castlepines · Mar 17, 2014

This is the time you cook a butt to a temp rather than probe tender. I agree that 160-165 should do it, just like other pork products. Although 140 is the new accepted temp for pork, theres a lot more connective tissue in pork butt.

Probe tender: take something like a meat probe, thermometer probe, bamboo skewer, etc. When the meat is done the probe should slide right into it with very little effort. The connective tissue provides resistance. Once that is broken down, there is no resistance and the probe slides right in.

Lake Dogs · Mar 17, 2014

What they all said above; probably looking right at 180-185 internal temp to render as much fat and break down the tendons, etc.; no more...

That said, may I inquire as to why you prefer sliced vs. pulled? I ask this because there is a difference in pulled pork and shredded pork (which a lot of people call pulled). Shredded tends to get dry and loses a lot of the flavor. Pulled, if left in chunks roughly the size of your thumb, tends to hold the moisture and flavor MUCH better. I love pulled pork, and frankly dont care for shredded pork.

jpalaska · Mar 17, 2014

Lake Dogs said:
What they all said above; probably looking right at 180-185 internal temp to render as much fat and break down the tendons, etc.; no more...

That said, may I inquire as to why you prefer sliced vs. pulled? I ask this because there is a difference in pulled pork and shredded pork (which a lot of people call pulled). Shredded tends to get dry and loses a lot of the flavor. Pulled, if left in chunks roughly the size of your thumb, tends to hold the moisture and flavor MUCH better. I love pulled pork, and frankly dont care for shredded pork.

I don't know, maybe the pulled pork I've had so far has been more like the consistency of shredded meat. I think I'd like it better if I tried a portion with a little more bark and fat in it.

JP

SmittyJonz · Mar 17, 2014

I prefer chopped pork vs pulled/shredded - lil different taste n texture. I do butts but I take them off at IT of 185-190* and let them rest 1 hr then chunk n dice n chopp them. I also prefer Pork Shoulder Picnic cuz it has stronger taste. By the way Pork Butt Burnt Ends are Fantastalisous!!!!!

http://www.bbq-brethren.com/forum/showthread.php?t=182490

Rusty Kettle · Mar 17, 2014

190 is the sweet spot for sliced boneless seems better for slicing than bone in but bone in is better for pulled. Bit of bbq sauce over slices is really good.

gtr · Mar 17, 2014

I like pulled, chopped, shredded - all that - and I also really like sliced. I've had some very good sliced pork bbq - nothing wrong with that at all, and, as previously stated, you're looking at around 190 or maybe a little less for that methinks.

jpalaska · Mar 17, 2014

gtr said:
I like pulled, chopped, shredded - all that - and I also really like sliced. I've had some very good sliced pork bbq - nothing wrong with that at all, and, as previously stated, you're looking at around 190 or maybe a little less for that methinks.

Thanks. BTW, I love your dog's photo. Years ago I had a Doberman who lost an eye. Penny was one of the sweetest dogs I ever had.

JP

bwram1 · Mar 17, 2014

Pop into Belk in Morganton tomorrow and I'll try to change your mind about pulled...got 2 butts on the smoker as we speak.

4.5 hours into the cook

BigBellyBBQ · Mar 17, 2014

I have several customers that want it sliced, I cook to internal of 175,
160-165 did not seem tender however very tasty, flavor profile is different sliced.

N8man · Mar 17, 2014

when I do sliced, I cook pork picnics to around 170-180 internal temp and, this is the most important part, wrap tightly and rest for at least an hour, two is better, before slicing...lets the juices redistribute....mighty tasty!!!

Garyclaw · Mar 17, 2014

I like to slice sometimes, and when I do, I'll smoke it a day ahead and pull the bone out, then let cool and into the frig. Next day I put on my slicer and slice as thin or thick as I want ( usually thin) then re-heat. It slices much better when it's cold. Or if your're eating in that day, do what N8 said, for 2 hrs. To avoid dryness the next day, I'll drizzle w/ a mixture of sauce and some kind of stock.

jpalaska · Mar 17, 2014

bwram1 said:
Pop into Belk in Morganton tomorrow and I'll try to change your mind about pulled...got 2 butts on the smoker as we speak.

4.5 hours into the cook

Lord have mercy! Those look porktacular!
What's Belk?
JP

bwram1 · Mar 17, 2014

jpalaska said:
What's Belk?
JP

Belk department store...Belk is the largest privately owned department store chain in the country. 300+ stores...owned 100% by the Belk family. I am the Loss Prevention Manager at the Morganton store. I catch the shoplifters.

Address is C102 Morganton Heights Blvd...if you decide to try some of what's in that pic.

Happy Hapgood · Mar 17, 2014

I like to use a center cut eye of round for slicing.

deguerre · Mar 17, 2014

Eye of round on a pig?

Sliced Pork Rather Than Pulled

Full Fledged Farker

Babbling Farker

is Blowin Smoke!

is Blowin Smoke!

Full Fledged Farker

is Blowin Smoke!

Quintessential Chatty Farker

Full Fledged Farker

somebody shut me the fark up.

Babbling Farker

somebody shut me the fark up.

Full Fledged Farker

is one Smokin' Farker

is Blowin Smoke!

Babbling Farker

Babbling Farker

Full Fledged Farker

is one Smokin' Farker

somebody shut me the fark up.

somebody shut me the fark up.

Similar threads